In the income approach, a small change in the capitalization or discount rate can move a unit value by a large amount. That is why cost of capital appeared in both WPTC tracks in 2026: Dr. Hal Heaton taught Cost of Capital Parts 1 and 2 in the Principles Course, and Anas Aboulamer of Kroll presented on cost of capital in the Advanced Course[3].
This article explains the building blocks using one public, current example: the Montana Department of Revenue’s 2026 Capitalization Rate Study for centrally assessed property[1]. Other states use different data and judgments; Montana is used here because its narrative is published and detailed.
Where the rate fits in the income approach
The Lincoln Institute chapter on the unit approach lists two main income indicators for utilities and transportation companies: perpetuity capitalization and discounted cash flow[2]. Montana’s study mirrors this with two kinds of rates[1]:
- Direct capitalization rates, applied to a single year’s benefit stream (Montana develops rates for net operating profit after tax and for “gross” cash flow).
- Yield capitalization rates, used to discount a stream of projected future (free) cash flows to present value.
The study stresses that the cash flow used in yield capitalization is “true,” “net,” or “free” cash flow, not the “gross” cash flow used in the direct gross cash flow indicator. When a company does not provide a projected cash flow stream, the department normalizes historical free cash flows instead[1].
Band of investment (WACC)
Montana develops a rate for each centrally assessed industry group using the band-of-investment technique, also known as the weighted average cost of capital. The typical industry rate for each source of capital (common equity and debt) is weighted by its proportion in the typical market capital structure for that industry. The rates are taken from directly observed market information[1].
In simple form, a WACC is the equity weight times the cost of equity, plus the debt weight times the cost of debt. Montana’s narrative also notes that the present value of operating leases reported by guideline companies is included in the debt portion, and it describes how preferred stock is measured[1].
Guideline companies
The market data come from guideline companies, publicly traded firms in the same industry. Montana takes its universe from the appropriate industry group in the Value Line Investment Survey and then tests it against industry-specific criteria before selecting the final set[1].
The cost of debt: current yield vs. yield to maturity
The study draws a distinction that often confuses newcomers[1]:
- Current yield is the annual coupon divided by price. Montana uses it for direct capitalization.
- Yield to maturity is the rate that equates the present value of a bond’s cash flows to its current price, assuming it is held to maturity. Montana uses it for yield capitalization.
The narrative observes that the two generally do not vary significantly for seasoned issues and are the same for new issues. Yield-capitalization debt rates come from Mergent, Inc., grouped by credit rating and matched to each industry’s average rating[1].
The cost of equity
For direct capitalization: earnings multiples
For direct capitalization of NOPAT, Montana uses the price-to-earnings ratio, computed from year-end closing prices and both historic and projected earnings per share from Value Line, and then selects an industry rate based on the quality and quantity of the data[1]. A parallel price-to-cash-flow ratio supports the gross cash flow indicator.
For yield capitalization: CAPM and DDM
For the yield rate, the cost of equity is estimated with several methods, including two variants of the dividend discount model (DDM) and two variants of the capital asset pricing model (CAPM)[1]. The study states the CAPM formula as:
ke = Rf + β × ERP, where ke is the cost of equity, Rf the risk-free rate, β the beta, and ERP the equity risk premium[1].
- Risk-free rate: the yield on a 20-year constant-maturity U.S. government bond as reported by the Federal Reserve, chosen to match the term used for the equity risk premium.
- Beta: selected from an analysis of the guideline companies’ betas in the Value Line Investment Analyzer.
- Equity risk premium: market return less the risk-free rate, selected from several independent sources, both ex-post (historical) and ex-ante (forward-looking).
Why judgment still matters
None of these inputs is mechanical. Choices about which guideline companies to include, which capital structure is “typical,” and how to weigh DDM against CAPM all affect the result. The Lincoln chapter makes a related point about the whole appraisal: when approaches disagree, the appraiser must weigh the quality of the data and reach a final opinion through correlation[2]. For the bigger picture, read the unit valuation primer.
Learning this at WPTC
If you are building your first rate study or reviewing someone else’s, the Principles Course cost of capital sessions are a structured place to start, and the Advanced Course covers current research[3]. Compare the tracks in our track guide. [2027 session list TBD – not yet published]





